PayPal Holdings Inc. finds itself in a precarious position once again, as doubts linger among some investors on Wall Street regarding the company’s ability to successfully execute its turnaround plan. PayPal’s shares have tumbled in premarket trading, with analysts expressing skepticism about the effectiveness of the company’s recent efforts.
Wells Fargo analyst Andrew Bauch, despite acknowledging the “bold efforts” made by PayPal’s management to revitalize the company’s story, remains doubtful about the company’s latest results and outlook. Bauch suggests that these results are more likely to support the skeptics rather than inspire confidence in potential investors. He specifically emphasizes the need for PayPal to address the competitive pressures it faces in its core checkout button business.
Bauch also states that while he appreciates the new management team’s energy, he warns that turning around a company of PayPal’s size will be no easy task. Despite his reservations, Bauch maintains an equal-weight rating and a target price of $60 for the stock.
Following an innovation event held by PayPal in late January, Jefferies analyst Trevor Williams questions whether the latest earnings report could be a turning point for the stock. Williams highlights that while the outlooks for gross profit and EPS may provide some stability for future estimates, committing substantial investments to fix existing problems, such as loss of market share in branded checkout, could be risky and potentially irreparable. Williams also points out that including stock-based compensation in adjusted EPS may limit the stock’s potential in the short term, given its already high valuation relative to growth.
As a result of these concerns, PayPal’s shares have declined by 9% in premarket trading.
PayPal’s recent earnings report has failed to fully assuage investor skepticism about its ability to overcome challenges and achieve a successful turnaround. Questions surrounding competitive pressures and the effectiveness of management’s strategy continue to weigh on Wall Street’s perception of the company. It remains to be seen whether PayPal can regain investor confidence and deliver the results needed to sustain future growth.
PayPal’s New Leadership and Vision
Some financial analysts have expressed their views on PayPal’s recent leadership changes and the company’s new direction. While there is generally positive sentiment towards the new executive team, concerns remain about the timeline for implementing their vision.
Piper Sandler analyst Kevin Barker is encouraged by the changes made by newly appointed CEO Alex Chriss. Barker believes that Chriss has taken steps to address PayPal’s challenges, which could lead to sustained revenue and margin growth. However, Barker cautions that these efforts will take time to yield tangible results, and he has adjusted his price target to $62.
Susquehanna analyst James Friedman commends PayPal’s new management team for focusing on transaction dollars, a move that he believes will positively impact both the company’s margin and stock price. However, Friedman also highlights PayPal’s decision to prioritize enhancements to Core PayPal, which he considers to be the weaker aspect compared to Braintree. As a result, Friedman is cautiously optimistic about the potential upside but advises against drawing conclusions too soon. He has maintained a neutral rating with a $65 target price.
Barclays analyst Ramsey El-Assal recognizes that PayPal is undergoing a reset phase, as reflected in its outlook. Despite expecting some short-term setbacks, El-Assal believes that this approach is the right one. He anticipates a pullback in shares but remains optimistic about a clearer and cleaner setup emerging in the future. El-Assal rates the stock at overweight with a $81 target price.
In summary, analysts have varying opinions on PayPal’s new leadership and vision. While there is optimism about the changes being made, concerns remain about the timeline for achieving desired outcomes. The market will closely watch as the company continues to navigate its transformation and assess its future performance.